Recirculation Ballot Desktop

HL7 Healthcare Privacy and Security Classification System, Release 1 (September 2013 Ballot Cycle Normative 1 Ballot)


HL7 Healthcare Privacy and Security Classification System, Release 1

This is a recirculation of the Normative 1 ballot from the September 2013 Ballot Cycle .

Recirculation Ballot Overview:
Two voters lodged several negative comments against this ballot, dealing with the tagging and handling of sensitive data, the failure to include lists to classify data for more real-world uses, and the failure to detail the down-sides of the system used in this approach. The WG found these comments not persuasive because the HCS is agnostic on policy and is not intended to be prescriptive.

Recirculation Ballot Announcement Package

Ballot Open Date: 6-Jan-2014
Ballot Close Date: 20-Jan-2014

Voting for this recirculation ballot is closed.

Sponsoring WG: Security (opens in new window)

Ballot Summary

Ballot Summary – Total Voters in Consensus Group: 148
Ballot Open Date – 01/06/2014
Ballot Close Date – 01/20/2014
Total Affirmatives Needed for Passage (75% Approval): 50
(Approval is achieved against the total number of affirmative and negative votes, 66.)
  Original Vote   Recirculation
Vote
  Final Tally
Affirmative:   81      81
Negative:   3      
Abstain:   53        53 
Note: Final Tally represents a tally of each voter's last vote, whether that is the original vote or the re-circulation vote. A vote during the re-circulation period over-rides (or re-affirms) that voter's original vote. If a voter does not return a vote during this re-circulation period, that voter's original vote remains in effect.

Ballot Summary by Voter Type

  Aff. Neg. Abst. NV
Affiliate 33 1 20 1
Consultant 5 1 5 4
Government/University 6 1 2 1
Provider 27 0 14 2
Vendor 10 0 12 3
Totals: 81 3 53 11
Percentage of Total (148): 54.73 % 2.03 % 35.81 % 7.43 %

Click here to view the full Tally Detail listing all voters and votes.

Initial Ballot Details

Ballot Tally: HL7 Healthcare Privacy and Security Classification System, Release 1 (opens in new window)
Initial Ballot Reconciliation Spreadsheet